When Gardner Minshew joined the Raiders in free agency, he landed an opportunity to win a starting role. That decision was made in spite of a desire on the part of his former team to keep him in place. 
Minshew signed with the Colts last offseason, following Shane Steichen from Philadelphia to Indianapolis. The latter served as the Eagles’ offensive coordinator before taking the Colts’ head coaching gig. The pair continued to work together after Anthony Richardson‘s season-ending shoulder injury thrust Minshew into the starting lineup. After proving his value on a one-year contract, though, Minshew signed a two-year, $25MM Raiders pact.
Indianapolis wanted to re-sign the 2023 Pro Bowler, Vic Tafur of The Athletic notes (subscription required). The Colts were not, however, prepared to match the $15MM in guarantees Minshew secured from the Raiders. With Richardson still in place on his rookie pact (and positioned to be at full health in time for the start of the year), the Colts elected to add Joe Flacco as a new veteran insurance option.
In Vegas, Minshew has spent the offseason competing with Aidan O’Connell for the QB1 gig. The latter had a spell atop the depth chart to close out last season, and he frequently received praise from head coach Antonio Pierce leading up to the draft. After being heavily linked with Jayden Daniels, the Raiders did not select a signal-caller in April, paving the way for a true Minshew-vs.-O’Connell competition in training camp. No decision on a winner has been made yet, but a commitment is expected after Vegas’ second preseason contest. Minshew does not plan to alter his preparation in the future regardless of if he gets the nod for 2024.
“If I knew a better way of doing things, I would have been doing it, you know?” the 28-year-old said. “So you just keep going, trust the process, continue learning and get better. And, you know, support whatever decision [Pierce] makes.”
Over $3MM of Minshew’s 2025 base salary is guaranteed, so he has a strong chance of remaining with the Raiders regardless of how the coming season plays out. If he handles a heavy workload as he did last year, attention will turn to the Colts’ plan under center and how well Flacco performs if he is called into action.